|
|
Post by johnjohnson on Dec 15, 2007 20:57:02 GMT 1
who has played the best for us over this season so far? I'll start by saying fuck knows. Possibly Kamara, but he's still the most erratic football player ever.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 15, 2007 20:59:23 GMT 1
Holdsworth. IMO the most consistent and always gives 100%.
|
|
|
|
Post by marshterrier on Dec 15, 2007 21:00:45 GMT 1
The guy who did the fancy keepy ups at the Port Vale game, Billy Wingrove.
|
|
|
|
Post by iandunnsbarber on Dec 15, 2007 21:33:15 GMT 1
Bit boring but it has got to be Boothy. We only perform consistently when he is in the team
|
|
|
|
Post by wildbillthetownfan on Dec 15, 2007 22:48:21 GMT 1
Theres not many to choose from, but it would have to be Boothy for me. It would be easier to choose the non-player of the season so far? and for me its Schofield. He just is'nt the same player.
|
|
|
|
Post by Viva La Terrier's on Dec 15, 2007 22:56:48 GMT 1
I'd go for Boothy so far but i think Williams will be our star man come the end of the season.
|
|
chris72
Chris Hay Terrier
Posts: 84
|
Post by chris72 on Dec 15, 2007 23:04:16 GMT 1
I agree,definately on todays showing.By the end of the season,Williams.So far,Wallwork.
|
|
|
|
Post by panasonicgeese on Dec 16, 2007 16:29:03 GMT 1
Holdsworth
|
|
|
|
Post by LordyOfTheManor on Dec 16, 2007 17:03:48 GMT 1
only one contender at the moment for me. got to be boothy for me.
|
|
|
|
Post by kamaraisking on Dec 16, 2007 17:38:38 GMT 1
holdsworth for me 100% player
|
|
|
|
Post by yorkterrier on Dec 16, 2007 18:00:37 GMT 1
who has played the best for us over this season so far? I'll start by saying fuck knows. Possibly Kamara, but he's still the most erratic football player ever. No offence JJ, but are you mad? Kamara is pants - he manages a decent cross once or twice a month and spends the rest of the time drifting between defence and attack, in no mans land! Wallwork, williams and possibly worthy if he gets back in. |
|
|
|
Post by kamaraisking on Dec 16, 2007 18:15:42 GMT 1
One question yorkterrier who would u rather have on the right brandon or kammy  |
|
|
|
Post by terrierng on Dec 16, 2007 18:31:51 GMT 1
the question isnt about brandon versus kamara though its player of the season,i cant think of any outstanding player yet,but for the record its kamara over brandon all day for me.
|
|
|
|
Post by yorkterrier on Dec 16, 2007 18:38:38 GMT 1
One question yorkterrier who would u rather have on the right brandon or kammy Neither, to be honest, I think they are both poor. Kam is a winger, not a right midfielder so his job surely, is to receive the ball and take on the full back (it doesnt help that his second touch is a tackle), but he has neither trickery , nor pace (I mean real pace!). Having said that, what use is pace when the ageing boothy would not be able to meet the cross (?) into the box. Also, he sits in between defecne and attack and then ends up doing neither (Ben Thornley was the same). I think he was crap yesterday, yet 10 people have already voted him man of the match! Its all a game of opinions I supose! |
|
|
|
Post by terrierng on Dec 16, 2007 18:43:22 GMT 1
i must disagree about him having no pace,hes bags of it,he may not use it correctly but has it all the same,rest of your post is about right though.
|
|
|
|
Post by kamaraisking on Dec 16, 2007 19:35:23 GMT 1
kammy will hit double figures this season not bad for a right winger whos crap  |
|
|
|
Post by sinister on Dec 16, 2007 19:41:21 GMT 1
who has played the best for us over this season so far? I'll start by saying fuck knows. Possibly Kamara, but he's still the most erratic football player ever. No offence JJ, but are you mad? Kamara is pants - he manages a decent cross once or twice a month and spends the rest of the time drifting between defence and attack, in no mans land! Wallwork, williams and possibly worthy if he gets back in. Yes, it's a game of opinions, and in my opinion Kamara has been our best player this season. Kamara has scored 5 goals and is our most dangerous player, if that's "pants" then I'm glad you're not in charge of team affairs. However, as you said, it's a game of opinions. |
|
|
|
Post by specialun on Dec 16, 2007 22:14:44 GMT 1
Holdsworth, Kamara, Booth in that order. Holdsworth - more assists than anyone else in the division. Considering we are scoring less than one a game, that means he is almost making half our goals! Negative move by ritchie to move him to right back imo. Most consistent player and one of the few players intent on two touch, high tempo, wanting the ball, playing it wide, pass and move, retention of the ball football. Kamara - Yorkterrier, you clearly don't like kamara, but i ask what he is supposed to do! He hasn't the best touch but at this level its about getting the best out of what you have. He has 5 goals from midfield, he has won more freekicks for us than any other player (including boothy) and more opposition players have been booked for fouls on kamara than any other player. He scored in thw in at milwall, the winner against swansea and almost single handedly won us the game at accrington. Add his work ethic to that and you cannot complain. Work on his crossing and he could become lethal at this level. Our problem is he is our only outlet ball other than to boothy...cut the supply to him and have 2/3 mark him and we struggle as the lhs of midfield is non existent. Boothy- 2 goals in 11 games - terrible! Boothy is boothy, we conceded 10 headers in the games before he came back into the side. All of a sudden, we are not conceding from set pieces as often! Coincidence? Not at all. Our record with and without him playing speaks volumes. |
|
|
|
Post by SN0W on Dec 16, 2007 22:23:32 GMT 1
keogh...... only joshing........ so far probably Booth, Kamara, Holdsworth neck-and-neck
|
|
|
|
Post by Michael Moon on Dec 16, 2007 22:35:56 GMT 1
Its got to be Worthington, for the first proper tackle a Town player has made this season!!!
|
|
|
|
Post by yorkterrier on Dec 16, 2007 23:14:27 GMT 1
Holdsworth, Kamara, Booth in that order. Holdsworth - more assists than anyone else in the division. Considering we are scoring less than one a game, that means he is almost making half our goals! Negative move by ritchie to move him to right back imo. Most consistent player and one of the few players intent on two touch, high tempo, wanting the ball, playing it wide, pass and move, retention of the ball football. Kamara - Yorkterrier, you clearly don't like kamara, but i ask what he is supposed to do! He hasn't the best touch but at this level its about getting the best out of what you have. He has 5 goals from midfield, he has won more freekicks for us than any other player (including boothy) and more opposition players have been booked for fouls on kamara than any other player. He scored in thw in at milwall, the winner against swansea and almost single handedly won us the game at accrington. Add his work ethic to that and you cannot complain. Work on his crossing and he could become lethal at this level. Our problem is he is our only outlet ball other than to boothy...cut the supply to him and have 2/3 mark him and we struggle as the lhs of midfield is non existent. Boothy- 2 goals in 11 games - terrible! Boothy is boothy, we conceded 10 headers in the games before he came back into the side. All of a sudden, we are not conceding from set pieces as often! Coincidence? Not at all. Our record with and without him playing speaks volumes. Opinon was conclusive when I watched him at Bell End road with the International coach form The Gambia, who described him as 'lazy'! Having played pro football myself (with 4 players who went onto represent England), I think I have a good eye for a player. Granted he has scored good goals ('wall' and 'accy'), but as a winger give me, say, Beagrie anytime. Unless im mistaken, he is not there to win fucking free kicks. You dont expect us to score from a set piece do you? In any event, the only reason he wins em is cis he hits the deck when any contact is made. Several times in the first half, the midfield are reluctant to give him the ball because we always concede. I tell you what, what about a ball inside the full back, never happens! Rant over, Becks is on 'Parky', got the same suit on that he wore for the Hatton fight, tight sod. |
|
|
|
Post by sinister on Dec 16, 2007 23:24:26 GMT 1
Holdsworth, Kamara, Booth in that order. Holdsworth - more assists than anyone else in the division. Considering we are scoring less than one a game, that means he is almost making half our goals! Negative move by ritchie to move him to right back imo. Most consistent player and one of the few players intent on two touch, high tempo, wanting the ball, playing it wide, pass and move, retention of the ball football. Kamara - Yorkterrier, you clearly don't like kamara, but i ask what he is supposed to do! He hasn't the best touch but at this level its about getting the best out of what you have. He has 5 goals from midfield, he has won more freekicks for us than any other player (including boothy) and more opposition players have been booked for fouls on kamara than any other player. He scored in thw in at milwall, the winner against swansea and almost single handedly won us the game at accrington. Add his work ethic to that and you cannot complain. Work on his crossing and he could become lethal at this level. Our problem is he is our only outlet ball other than to boothy...cut the supply to him and have 2/3 mark him and we struggle as the lhs of midfield is non existent. Boothy- 2 goals in 11 games - terrible! Boothy is boothy, we conceded 10 headers in the games before he came back into the side. All of a sudden, we are not conceding from set pieces as often! Coincidence? Not at all. Our record with and without him playing speaks volumes. Opinon was conclusive when I watched him at Bell End road with the International coach form The Gambia, who described him as 'lazy'! Having played pro football myself (with 4 players who went onto represent England), I think I have a good eye for a player. Granted he has scored good goals ('wall' and 'accy'), but as a winger give me, say, Beagrie anytime. Unless im mistaken, he is not there to win fucking free kicks. You dont expect us to score from a set piece do you? In any event, the only reason he wins em is cis he hits the deck when any contact is made. Several times in the first half, the midfield are reluctant to give him the ball because we always concede. I tell you what, what about a ball inside the full back, never happens! Rant over, Becks is on 'Parky', got the same suit on that he wore for the Hatton fight, tight sod. So you watched the game with the International Manafer from Gambia and expect his "comments" to convince us that Kamara is not a good player. Also spouting off about your credentials isnt going to make you OPINION any more credible. Kamara was our best player at Elland road (I was there too), and I've also played at a decent level. Kamara was the ONLY play who hurt Leeds in the first half, what game were you watching. He was also the ONLY player who Bristol Rovers were clearly wary of. He wins free-kicks because opposition at this level tend to kick the more dangerous players. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 16, 2007 23:28:46 GMT 1
Guess it shows playing pro football doesn't mean you know that much about it then |
|
|
|
Post by johnjohnson on Dec 17, 2007 0:04:00 GMT 1
who has played the best for us over this season so far? I'll start by saying fuck knows. Possibly Kamara, but he's still the most erratic football player ever. No offence JJ, but are you mad? Kamara is pants - he manages a decent cross once or twice a month and spends the rest of the time drifting between defence and attack, in no mans land! Wallwork, williams and possibly worthy if he gets back in. Player of the season so far can't be Worthy or Williams as they simply haven't played enough. I don't like Kamara as a player, sometimes it's like he doesn't realise how fast he is, and i agree about his crossing being pants most of the time, but the only other player that is anywhere near him is Holdsworth for me.... |
|
|
|
Post by kilroy on Dec 17, 2007 0:36:12 GMT 1
Guess it shows playing pro football doesn't mean you know that much about it then Nar it doesnt...However anyone that says Kamara is crap also means that the person commenting upon him has no idea what he/she is on about either! |
|
|
|
Post by upthetown on Dec 17, 2007 9:05:33 GMT 1
haha! Hang on am I right in thinking your saying someone else does'nt know much about football after you have called kamara crap....... oh dear....pot kettle black springs to mind. Guess it shows playing pro football doesn't mean you know that much about it then |
|
|
|
Post by sinister on Dec 17, 2007 9:26:54 GMT 1
This thread is about the Player of the Season so far, not about any given players strengths and weaknesses.
Yes, Kamara has a few weaknesses, however, he wouldnt be playing in League One if he wasthe complete Winger.
However, what is not up for the debate is the fact that for all these weaknesses, he has still been our best player this season.
|
|
|
|
Post by HuddsTerrier on Dec 17, 2007 11:53:49 GMT 1
On two contenders at the mo for me, Holdsworth and Kamara
|
|
|
|
Post by yorkterrier on Dec 17, 2007 12:08:26 GMT 1
Opinon was conclusive when I watched him at Bell End road with the International coach form The Gambia, who described him as 'lazy'! Having played pro football myself (with 4 players who went onto represent England), I think I have a good eye for a player. Granted he has scored good goals ('wall' and 'accy'), but as a winger give me, say, Beagrie anytime. Unless im mistaken, he is not there to win fucking free kicks. You dont expect us to score from a set piece do you? In any event, the only reason he wins em is cis he hits the deck when any contact is made. Several times in the first half, the midfield are reluctant to give him the ball because we always concede. I tell you what, what about a ball inside the full back, never happens! Rant over, Becks is on 'Parky', got the same suit on that he wore for the Hatton fight, tight sod. So you watched the game with the International Manafer from Gambia and expect his "comments" to convince us that Kamara is not a good player. Also spouting off about your credentials isnt going to make you OPINION any more credible. Kamara was our best player at Elland road (I was there too), and I've also played at a decent level. Kamara was the ONLY play who hurt Leeds in the first half, what game were you watching. He was also the ONLY player who Bristol Rovers were clearly wary of. He wins free-kicks because opposition at this level tend to kick the more dangerous players. You should have gone to Soho Square fella, if 'credentials' dont mean anything in football, you might have walked straight into the England job! Kamara has several good runs at Leeds in the first 20 minutes, then went missing for the rest of the game. Players dont 'kick' dangerous players! 20 years ago they did, but anymore! They call them names and try and talk them out of it and mark them good and close. If he was getting 'kicked' every 2 minutes he would be off injured all the time. Sorry, I thought we were playing players BETTER than this division, with a view to moving onwards and upwards but you are clearly happy with Div 3 players. We have comments on this thread that admit he cannot trap a ball and cannot cross, yet they still claim him to be a good player. He is a winger for f*cks sake! |
|
|
|
Post by HuddsTerrier on Dec 17, 2007 12:29:20 GMT 1
From what I've seen there are not too many talented people at Soho Square...
Wembley overspend
McClaren appointment
Matt Glennons red card not getting rescinded
In fact do they get anything right?
|
|
